Years ago, I wrote a review of the Macross TV series. I wanted to hyperlink to it recently while writing another review, but realized that it came from an old website which I never updated and has now been lost in time. So I'm reposting this review. Macross was one of the best shows out and still holds up well today, and it turns out that my AnimEigo set is now a collector's item. Who knew?
Introduction
I first saw Macross when I was a kid of about 15 in Singapore,
rushing home from school every Thursday evening to try to catch the
latest episode, which had been dubbed into Mandarin by the
Taiwanese. My
brother recently got a DVD
player, borrowed the entire TV series (36 episodes) from his friend
Jason, and we watched it all over again, this time in the original
Japanese with Chinese subtitles. What a difference 13 years make!
Macross is a girl’s story
For some reason, when you’re a kid, you don’t
notice that Macross is really a girl’s story. Sure, it’s got
giant transforming robots. It’s also got space batttles, lots of
neat gadgets, and a cool science fiction plot that stands up even to
adult scrutiny (well, the corny parts of the science fiction plot are
motivated by the romantic bent of the whole series). But the heart and
soul of Macross is the romance between the main
characters. Nobody’s motivated by anything else!
The plot revolves around 3 main characters. Hikaru Ichijou, a boy
pilot who grows up eventually to be a squadron leader, Linn Minmei
(also spelled Lynn MinMay), a school girl of about 16 who wins a beauty
contest and goes on to become a pop singer, and Misa Hayase (a good
translation might be Lisa Hayes, which the American "Robotech" uses), a
flight controller/battle coordinator for the ship, Macross. Of course,
there’s a love triangle between them, and how the interaction between
the characters play out and whom Hikaru eventually decides in favor of
presents the series with its romantic climax. To give you an idea of how
unimportant the military climax was, it occurs fully 8 episodes before
the end of the series, to give the creators more time to focus on what
was obviously dear to their hearts. The science fiction elements of the
plot are discussed elsewhere (see below for a collection of links to
various home pages), so I won’t go into them in detail.
So, ok, Macross is a trashy romance/soap opera. But if all soap
operas were like this I’d watch them. None of the characters are
stilted or artificial. Hikaru seems like a dork at times, but he does
wake up to his situations and corrects himself. Lynn Minmei seems like
your stereotypical cute airhead at first, but even she has to suffer
the consequences of her decisions and becomes a stronger person. Misa
Hayase seems like a rigid, strictly military person, but she suffers
from her own bouts of insecurities and when she eventually gives in to
her feelings becomes such a sympathetic character that you find
yourself rooting for her. Nobody’s a bad guy (or a bad girl), and
character development is handled consistently and with great
care. Everybody has to suffer a little in order to grow up, and the
primary characters in Macross are not immune to suffering. A common
theme seems to be that the characters have to let go of their desires in
order to deserve what they desire. But unlike the morality
plays you see in Saturday morning cartoons, these themes are handled
very subtly (so subtly that they were lost on me, of course, when I
was a kid).
How has Macross aged over the last 15 years for me personally? What
I’ve found is that the situations I found myself in over the last
10 years or so were in some ways paralleled in Macross. There are lots
of little touches, like in the ambiguous way Minmei treats Hikaru
throughout most of the series was something I’ve encountered in the
Asian dating scene. It is entirely possible that if you're not
familiar with how Asian-Asian dating works a very few of the cultural cues
might not work for you. There are some poignant moments, like the time
when Misa Hayase waits a whole day at a road side café for
Hikaru, who shows up in the evening after being much delayed. While
Misa is waiting, a little friendly dog comes up to her and she looks
at him and says, "Hey, you’re alone too." She picks him
up and starts feeding him but in the middle of it the dog’s owner
(a little girl that we can’t quite see) shouts the dog’s name
from across the street and the dog leaps out of Misa’s arms and
bounds towards the little girl. Hikaru shows up right after that and
the parallels that the preceding scene has with Misa's relationship
with Hikaru and Minmei just about broke my heart. These quiet scenes
become by far the most powerful ones. They have a
haunting quality that sticks with you even after you’re done
watching the series.
While technology mostly stays in the background, the characters in
Macross are facile with it, and use it naturally as part of day-to-day
life. In one episode, for instance, as Hikaru escorts Misa's shuttle
towards Earth, he sends a farewell message to her by signalling
(in Morse code) with the wing-tip lights on his fighter.
There are quite a number of corny scenes however. Given the series'
preoccupation with romance, it shouldn't surprise you that characters
find themselves working through their issues while bombs are literally
falling around them. But then again, I've already told you that
Macross is a trashy romance, haven't I?
One of the things I missed watching the series in Singapore was the
end title credits. The end credit sequence shows a helmet, and a photo
album. A hand moves in and turns the photo album’s pages, revealing
photographs of Minmei, and Minmei and Hikaru. The helmet is a standin
for Hikaru’s pilot’s helmet, but what you don’t realize is
that the hand moving the photo album isn’t Hikaru’s (the helmet
doesn't belong to Hikaru, either)! The scene shows up 28 episodes into
the series. The final episode ends with a freeze-frame, and a hand
turns the page over to the end of the photo album while the caption
comes up "2012: So long!", giving one a sense of closure
about the story as a whole. The end theme is also sung by a different
performer for the last episode. It is little touches like that that
distinguish the long running Japanese/Asian TV series from the
American series. It is quite obvious that Macross was a story planned
with a beginning, middle, climax, and end right from the start, while
American series (except for the mini-series, which don't typically run
as long as the Asian series) do not usually have the coherency of a
single vision guiding their work.
Animation
All TV animation series have to be relatively low
budget. Watching all 36 episodes in order in relatively short time gives
you a very good sense as to which episodes were important to the
producers. There are entire episodes that seem stitched togther from
flashbacks in order to either let the audience catch up from the
previous episode or in order to meet a deadline. Then there are episodes
like the military climax, or the last 4 episodes of the series, where
the producers pull out all stops---the machines and ships look almost
real, and the women and men look gorgeous. It almost looks as if Misa
Hayase underwent a facelift in the last 8 episodes of the series! Even
in the best-drawn episodes, however, budget seems a primary
consideration: you can definitely recognize battle scenes that have been
cut and spliced from previous episodes. However, don’t let this deter
you—even the badly drawn episodes have the virtue that the story line is
consistently high quality. There’s an episode devoted to Hikaru’s dream
sequence that is hilarious, for instance. It is not at all unusual to
find humor thrown into the mix to good effect, and even the serious
episodes can have a bit of farce thrown in.
Minmei's singing
A frequent source of derision whenever the Macross comes up among
anime fans is Minmei's pop songs. If you like
Japanese pop, there's nothing wrong with her performance. Iijima Mari
is a pop/idol singer who did voice-acting as Lynn Minmei when she was
nineteen (Minmei is 16 at the start of the TV series),
so not only was she a good fit for Minmei's voice, she could sing as
well. If your exposure to Minmei was through the American dubbed
series, you will definitely find Iijima Mari to be at least someone
who can hit the notes when she wants to. That said, however, even
Iijima Mari is embarrassed about the most overused song in Macross,
Watashi no Kare wa Pairotto (My boyfriend is a
pilot). Apparently, things that weren't embarrassing to sing when you
were nineteen have a way of catching up to you when you're 35. Well,
you can always fast-forward through the singing without missing
anything.
The background music in Macross is reasonably well-done. In fact, if
you watch any kind of Asian television, you will run into some
low-budget Taiwanese shows that have "borrowed" background music from
Macross. (Presumably, they just cut their background music from the
myriad CDs that have sprung up) If you're going to buy a soundtrack
album, the movie soundtrack has the best orchestrations.
Is it worth 18 hours?
So how do I feel about spending 18 hours watching this
series over a period of a few weeks? I’d do it again. I wouldn’t
do it unless I could watch all of it, since you will not be satisfied
without getting to know the climax and the ending, and there’s no
easy way to skip episodes without missing some character or plot
development. There is one catch-up episode around episode 12 that you
can skip because it’s used to catch laggards up with the series,
and that’s about it. If I had only 2 hours to spend, I’d
definitely just watch the last 4 episodes or perhaps the last 8
episodes if I had more time. (These are the "reconstruction of
Earth" episodes—other science fiction shows have the heroes
saving the world, this one has the heroes failing to save the Earth)
These episodes focus almost solely on the romance, but the caveat is
that you’ll miss a lot without getting the setup that the first
twenty-something episodes give you. For instance, Roy Fokker plays a
major part early on in the series, and episode 33 doesn’t make much
sense if you don’t know who he is. If you can, watch the series in
the original Japanese. Not only is the voice acting much better, but
you’ll get a stronger sense of what gets lost in the
translation. (I’ll never forgive whoever translated "Merry
Christmas" into a long awkward Chinese sentence!) There’s a
surprising amount of English in the TV series, too, so you might not
find yourself as lost as you might imagine.
The movie
A final
word before going into the hyperlinks. The movie isn’t the same
story as the TV series. If you’ve seen the movie, it will still be
worth your while to watch the TV series, just as it’s worth your
while to read a novel of a movie that was made from a novel. There are
many plot differences between the movie and the TV series. Outright
contradictions are common: in the TV series, Minmei is never kidnapped
by the Zentraedi, while in the movie, she was captured and persuades
the aliens to return her with her songs! Your feelings about the
characters will be much stronger if you watch the TV series. If you
had to choose one or the other (and given that the movie’s only 90
minutes but the TV series is 18 hours, they’re not quite
comparable), the TV series is definitely better. The movie, as might
be expected, has gorgeous animation, and if you want to see the
characters drawn at their best, that’s a good place to see them!
Web-sites
Just a note. I've tried to keep spoilers away from this review of
Macross in the hopes that you'll go ahead and try to watch it. Some of
the hyperlinks below contain spoilers that you might not want to
see. (In particular, the compendium site can be very dangerous)
- The Official
Macross Website. Hosted in Japan, this is a very poor site with
relatively few stills from the movie or the TV series. However, the
description of the characters in "Japlish" is hilarious! If you want
to see pictures of the characters I've mentioned, this site contains
no spoilers.
- The Macross Compendium. This is the mother of all fan-sites, and has a chronology as well as explanations of all the varying Macross TV series.