Don't Be Evil is Claire Stapleton's memoir of her 12 years at Google. It belongs in the same category of books as Exit Interview and Careless People. We should invent a new genre for these types of books. The story they tell goes like this:
- Bright talented fresh graduate or small company manager joins Big Tech (note: said woman must not be a software engineer or a technical professional of any sort)
- The narrator/protagonist swallows the Big Tech kool-aid, talking the corporate line about how the company she joined was going to be a positive force in the world
- Said narrator gets a bad boss who abuses her naivete and disabuses her of the notion that the powerful people in the company ever had the idea that the company was for anything other than making them as wealthy and powerful as possible
In any case, I will say that I wasn't one of the people who noticed Stapleton's work even when our times overlapped at Google. For one, by the time she joined I was already cynical and never paid attention to the TGIF e-mails. For another, software engineers, even those like me who were chewed and then spat out by Google have a completely different experience.
First, when I joined there were no make-work jobs in Software. At that time, robust, distributed computation was a novelty and the scale at which Google operated was uncommon. Secondly, engineers could and did make use of their 20% time so even if their primary job was soul-sucking (mine wasn't), they had an outlet for their creativity and Google was willing to fund that outlet with machines, interns and peers that were as smart or smarter than they were. I remember my experience blind e-mailing Adam Dingle who was the tech lead for Google Toolbar only to realize later that I knew him because he was my TA at Cal Berkeley. I watched Google recruit bright people I'd met over the years one at a time or via acquisition: almost my entire grad school class at the University of Washington. Adam DeBoor, who was a legend at Geoworks even when I worked there. Craig Chambers, who was Jeff Dean's PhD advisor. Unlike the sales and marketing organizations which were filled with Harvard, Stanford, or other Ivy League graduates as a pre-requisite, Google Engineering actually was to a large extent a meritocracy. (The promotion system was even more political than at other companies partly because Google could throw away infinite amounts of talent)
Anyway, Stapleton's memoir starts with her becoming the Bard of Google, writing TGIF e-mails with a distinctive Googley voice. (Even back then, whenever someone called me Googley I would cringe---it very quickly became a byword for "I approve" rather than having any special meaning for me) She went on to become the speechwriter for several execs. That's a great use of an English degree. I will note that she got frequent promotions, and even at the first job where she wasn't a fit she got a pretty good deal.
She only turned from Google after Google retaliated against her for the women's walkout. To be honest, even then she settled for much less than she could have gotten financially against Google, which to my mind meant that she didn't have the stomach for fighting it --- effectively she was rewarding Google for that retaliation, since Google would be incentivized to retaliate against anyone else who did what she did after she folded so quickly.
If you don't know much about Google's internal communications team, you'll learn a lot from reading this book. But I'm not sure it really can tell you much you don't already know --- corporate communications goal is to be as banal as possible while offending as few people as possible. Her stories and narrative felt much less coherent and disjointed than Careless People or even Exit Interview. Of course, she had to write the book during COVID and while managing 2 babies, but Sarah Wynn-Williams's book was written under similar circumstances, and her writing is much more compelling. I'm afraid to say that the Bard of Google isn't nearly as good as the policy lady at Facebook.
No comments:
Post a Comment